Pride at Pompey, intrigue at Ipswich

These are odd times at Plymouth Argyle, and I’m struggling to decide whether excitement or despondency is the appropriate attitude to take with regards to the remaining three months of the season. Perhaps tommorrow night’s play-off battle with Ipswich will provide us with some answers.

January must this far be regarded as a poor month for Argyle, with unrest in the dressing room, top players leaving, and a run of disappointing league results which has seen the Pilgrims drop from 5th to 11th. Indeed, we are without a league win in four matches, a run which stretches back to the Boxing Day victory over QPR, and Argyle’s last victory outside of Devon was the 1-0 success at Watford on December 15.

In addition, our two top scorers, Sylvan Ebanks-Blake and Barry Hayles, have been sold to Championship rivals Wolves and Leicester, with the third highest marksman, midfielder David Norris, looking likely to depart in the coming days – probably either to Leicester or tommorrow’s opponents.

The possibility of Norris heading to Suffolk seemed to increase with today’s announcement that he will take no part in the Ipswich tie. Paul Sturrock and the player have apparently come to this decision after much discussion at today’s training session, with Luggy saying:

"Disappointingly, there has been a lot of media coverage from a team that is very interested in David.

"I don’t think he would be mentally attuned to the tussle and I don’t think it would be fair of me to allow people to put the microscope on him. Every bad pass or mistake that he made would be highlighted."

This seems strange in some ways, given that the one thing rarely questioned of Norris is his unswerving commitment. It is still possible that he could remain with Argyle, but given his roots in Peterborough, within an hour of Ipswich, and his undoubted ambition to play top-flight football, the only way this will realistically happen is if the Tractor Boys cannot meet Argyle’s valuation. The situation is complicated by the sell-on clause negotiated by Bolton Wanderers when selling Norris to Argyle, which means they receive half of any fee. Even if Ipswich boss Jim Magilton caves in and offers a reasonable £2.5million, Plymouth would only collect £1.25m of the money.

Argyle’s hopes going into the trip to 8th-place Town have been further dashed by the injury to stalwart centre-half Marcel Seip, which also kept the Dutchman out of Saturday’s 2-1 FA Cup Fourth Round loss at Portsmouth.

‘The Dockyard Derby’ defeat, although initially disappointing, may eventually be seen as a blessing. Chris Clark’s early debut goal gave Argyle a real chance of shocking their Premiership hosts, and the pride and positive media coverage garnered from an unjust cup exit should boost morale in players and supporters alike.

Clark, a versatile Scottish attacking midfielder signed from Aberdeen a fortnight ago to little acclaim from the Green Army, could be another Sturrock find, and his fellow transfer window signing Yoann Folly has a chance to prove himself tommorrow night, replacing Norris. His eye-catching cameo role in the home draw with Southampton last week promised much.

Indeed, Sturrock has been putting the £4million received for the four players sold in January to good use, picking up talented players for low fees. This is his blueprint; hungry, committed players, moulded into a tight-knit, effective unit with flashes of flair. Clark cost £200k, and strikers Jermaine Easter from Wycombe and Jamie Mackie from Exeter were £210k and £145k respectively. Folly was free from Sheffield Wedneday, and Hungarian international midfielder Gyorgy Sandor became the latest arrival last week, the 23-year-old joining on loan from Ujpest in a similar buy-later deal which previously secured Krisztian Timar and Peter Halmosi. The ‘cherry on the cake’, as Luggy would say, was the club record £500k capture of striker Steve McLean from Cardiff.

The quality obviously present in this collection suggests that, with or without Norris, Argyle’s personnel may actually be of a higher standard at the end of the transfer window than when it began. This assertion could be shored up with a couple more bargains. Leigh Bromby from Sheffield United is a reported £400,000 target, and with the right-back area an Argyle weakness for several years, he’d be a shrewd acquisition. Rumours also abound of a bid for Oldham’s highly-rated centre-half Neal Trotman, now a real possibility after their ejection from the FA Cup at the hands of Huddersfield.

And Sturrock has said he wants another striker – could this be Derek Riordan, the Celtic man Argyle (or, at least, the Green Army) have allegedly coveted for more than a year? Probably not, as Burnley are currently the only club known to have made a bid, and the Celts are keen to sign Clarets striker Kyle Lafferty, so a swap deal looks on the cards.

Sturrock has made a habit, unlike Magilton, of keeping most of his transfer targets quiet, information sometimes only surfacing hours before an official announcement. So there may be some surprises in the coming days.

The eventual denouement of all this is that, after a tough four weeks, Argyle can go into February full of optimism and with a squad who are capable of relaunching a play-off charge, despite the current five-point gap. Lose at Ipswich though, and that dream will feel some huge Massey Ferguson tyres roll it slowly into the dirt.

RICH PARTINGTON

Argyle's Weekus Horribilis

My last blog predicted Sylvan Ebanks-Blake would be sold in the summer if Plymouth Argyle did not reach the Premiership this season. It’s a horrible cliché for a horrible seven days, but a week is a long time in football. SEB’s sharp finishing in the Hull game clearly focussed minds at Wolverhampton Wanderers and moneybags QPR, who both tabled bids of £1.5million.

It is my belief, despite much conjecture to the contrary on Argyle supporters messageboards, that the PAFC board would not have accepted this figure had it not triggered a release clause in Ebanks-Blake’s contract, meaning he was free to talk to any club who offered that amount. This clause, supposedly, was key to Argyle signing SEB from Manchester United in the first place, with Watford offering a similar deal. In the event, it seems the 21-year-old Cambridge-born striker couldn’t get out of Home Park fast enough. He had a miserable start to his Wolves career though, missing a good chance as his new side lost 3-0 at home to Crystal Palace. My heart bleeds for him, of course.

In a last-ditch attempt to hold on to Sylvan, Argyle proposed a new deal to make him the highest paid player in the club’s history. However, why did this not happen earlier? The board knew the release clause was present in the contract, and there was reported interest from Derby in September. It was obvious, from a fairly early stage of the season, that Ebanks-Blake would be an important player for the Pilgrims – so why was no attempt made to agree new terms, with the release fee increased or removed?

I am sure that if attempts such as this had been made, we would have heard about it, as the Argyle press relations department is always quick to justify announcements which disappoint the Green Army. As it is, despite much hysteria, Ebanks-Blake is Argyle’s only major loss of the transfer window thus far. Akos Buzsaky never really delivered for Plymouth and was nearing the end of his contract. Dan Gosling has great potential but was not a first team regular and there was no guarantee he would ever become one. And Barry Hayles fading ability to cope with the demands of this level has been apparent for some time now (although he did score for Leicester yesterday).

But what we are now left with is a paper-thin squad with more departures threatened. And a pile of money in the bank but no indication that enough of it will be spent on the fees, and more importantly wages, which will attract the necessary calibre of player for a real play-off push.

Yesterday’s gutless 1-0 defeat at Burnley, who had not won any of their previous nine home games, summed up the problems Paul Sturrock faces. Argyle had two untried, 18-year-old first-year professionals, Jake Moult and Dan Smith, on the bench, the latter appearing as substitute. And Lukas Jutkiewicz, the same age and in his first start on loan from Everton, must be wondering what he has let himself in for – forced to lead the line with Jermaine Easter on the right wing. Luggy must take some of the blame for this; while Ian Holloway was sometimes lacking tactically, he was usually less cautious away from home.

But the meagre resources the manager was left him with few options. Sturrock has promised that the players who lacked passion at Turf Moor, obviously deflated by SEB’s sale, will be whipped back into shape, and no one is better at this job that Luggy. But with Peter Halmosi a target for Wigan, with a £2.5million bid allegedly already turned down, David Norris attracting attention at around £1.5million, Argyle’s more talented players will be getting restless if the squad cannot be sufficiently bolstered.

Argyle need a real replacement for Ebanks-Blake – Derek Riordan from Celtic, Billy Sharp from Sheffield United, Freddy Eastwood of Wolves, that kind of player. He won’t come cheap, particularly wage-wise, but, for many greens, this week represents a crossroads in the club’s history.

We’ve been here before – both Tony Waiters in ‘75 and Dave Smith in ‘87 built sides which could have made a real challenge for elevation to the top flight, but neither received adequate support from the Argyle money-men. Now, in our best season in 20 years, Plymouth have a similar chance – and the same things seem to be happening.

So let me suggest something. We have just made more than £3.5million in transfer money – let’s reinvest it in the playing side, spending say just over £1million more than we would have done over the next three years. That means new signings, three-year-contracts – and upgrading the wage structure to give us a real shout of going up. Gates will increase if the fans see Argyle challenging to reach the Premiership for the first time. And if, in three years, we don’t make it, the ‘organic growth’ lobby can say "I told you so" and the rest of us will shut up.

One thing’s for certain though – like the teams of Waiters and Smith, without serious investment, the only way is down.

RICH PARTINGTON